Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

In "To One Who Said I Must Not Love," Sarah Fyge Egerton addresses an unnamed figure who has advised her against loving. The poem explores the intense and irresistible nature of love, which the speaker finds impossible to suppress despite societal expectations and personal suffering. Egerton employs vivid metaphors and striking imagery to convey the speaker's emotional turmoil, emphasizing themes of love, guilt, and the conflict between societal norms and personal desire.

The poem begins with a powerful declaration of the impossibility of suppressing love: "BID the fond mother spill her infant's blood, / The hungry epicure not think of food; / Bid the Antarctic touch the Arctic pole: / When these obey, I'll force love from my soul." These extreme metaphors highlight how natural love is to the speaker, as inherent and essential as a mother's care for her child or an epicure's desire for food.

The speaker likens her unity with love to the sun's essential components: "As light and heat compose the genial sun, / So love and I essentially are one." Despite advice to the contrary, she has tried to "ease the inherent pain," but her efforts were futile: "Though I resolved, and grieved, and almost died." Her attempts to suppress her feelings only deepened her sorrow.

Turning to social remedies, the speaker decided to "dilate the mighty flame, / Play the coquette, hazard my dearest fame." However, this approach did not alleviate her suffering, as "One thought of him contracts it all again." This suggests that her love is too deep and singular to be diluted or replaced.

In desperation, she turns to marriage for solace, seeking "cursed Hymen's aid." However, she finds that "the fettered soul has no repose," and she becomes "a double slave to love and vows." Her previous suffering is exacerbated by the added guilt of her marital commitment: "As if my former sufferings were too small, / I've made the guiltless torture criminal."

The speaker laments her inability to express her love freely, as she is now constrained by the rules of marriage: "But now these soft allays are so like sin, / I'm forced to keep the mighty anguish in." She must suppress her tender thoughts, "eager arms," and "longing eyes." Even her affection for a picture of her beloved is restrained: "My kindness to his picture I refrain, / Nor now embrace the lifeless, lovely swain."

The speaker finds herself gazing at her beloved's image, becoming as motionless as the "charming shade" she admires: "Till I become as motionless as that." Her emotional pain manifests physically, and she finds herself "Fainting, I lean against my frighted maid, / Whose cruel care restores my sense and pain." The moment she regains consciousness, she is overwhelmed by love again: "For soon as I have life I love again, / And with the fated softness strive in vain."

Egerton's speaker describes how love tears at her "struggling soul" and "racks like departing life." Each day, she endures the "torturing scene of death," as the sorrow of love continually renews itself.

The poem is written in rhymed couplets with lines in iambic pentameter, giving it a rhythmic and flowing quality that mirrors the speaker's emotional turbulence. The use of vivid metaphors and imagery underscores the intensity of the speaker's emotions and the gravity of her predicament.

In "To One Who Said I Must Not Love," Sarah Fyge Egerton crafts a passionate exploration of the conflict between societal norms and personal desire. By emphasizing the irresistible and essential nature of love, Egerton challenges the notion that love can be suppressed by external advice or social conventions. The poem is a testament to the emotional turmoil and inner conflict that arise when personal feelings clash with societal expectations, highlighting the universal struggle for authentic self-expression amid external pressures.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...