Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

In "Argument," Langston Hughes delivers a sharp and concise critique of racial prejudice, using direct and confrontational language to challenge the harmful stereotypes and beliefs that have been historically imposed on people of color. The poem exposes the absurdity of racial hierarchies and asserts a strong affirmation of Black identity and pride.

The poem opens with a series of racially charged phrases: "White is right, / Yellow mellow, / Black, get back!" These lines reflect common, deeply ingrained racist slogans and beliefs that have been used to justify discrimination and social inequality. "White is right" suggests that whiteness is inherently superior, while "Yellow mellow" conveys a more subtle form of racial hierarchy, implying that lighter-skinned people of color are more acceptable or less threatening than those with darker skin. The most overtly racist line, "Black, get back!" reflects the historical and ongoing marginalization and oppression of Black people.

Hughes then directly addresses the reader or an imagined interlocutor with the question, "Do you believe that, Jack?" This line serves as a challenge, prompting the reader to consider their own beliefs and attitudes toward race. The casual use of "Jack" adds an element of familiarity or colloquialism, making the question feel more immediate and personal.

The response, "Sure do!" indicates that the person being addressed accepts or believes in these racist ideas. However, Hughes swiftly condemns this acceptance with the blunt retort: "Then you're a dope / for which there ain't no hope." The use of "dope" here is both a slang term for a foolish person and a critique of the ignorance that underlies racist beliefs. By saying "there ain't no hope," Hughes implies that those who cling to such outdated and harmful ideas are beyond redemption or reason, trapped in their own narrow-mindedness.

The poem then shifts to a powerful affirmation: "Black is fine!" This line directly counters the previous racist slogans, asserting the inherent worth and dignity of Blackness. It is a declaration of self-respect and pride, rejecting the notion that Black people should be marginalized or devalued.

Hughes concludes the poem with the line, "And, God knows, / It's mine!" This final affirmation is both personal and universal. By invoking God, Hughes aligns his declaration with a higher moral authority, suggesting that the value of Black identity is not just a personal belief but a fundamental truth. The possessive "It's mine!" reinforces the idea that Blackness is something to be claimed with pride and confidence, an integral part of the speaker's identity that cannot be taken away or diminished by others.

"Argument" is a succinct yet powerful poem that challenges racist ideologies and affirms the worth of Black identity. Through its direct language and confrontational tone, Hughes calls out the absurdity of racial prejudice and asserts a strong, positive vision of Black self-worth. The poem serves as both a critique of societal racism and a declaration of pride, encouraging readers to reject harmful stereotypes and embrace the beauty and strength of their own identity.

Copyright (c) 2024 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...