Poetry Explorer

Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

BUCKET'S GOT A HOLE IN IT, by             Poet Analysis     Poet's Biography

"Bucket's Got a Hole in It" by William Matthews is a contemplative and somewhat sardonic exploration of secrets, memory, and the passage of time. The poem employs a mix of colloquial expressions and reflective musings to delve into the nature of what we choose to remember or forget, and the ways in which these choices shape our understanding of ourselves and the world.

The opening line, "Keep it under your hat, the saying went when we wore hats," invokes a nostalgic reference to a time when people wore hats and kept secrets close. This expression sets the tone for the poem, which examines how secrets are handled and the inevitability of their eventual revelation. The use of the verb "dissipate" to describe secrets leaving "the pate" (a playful nod to the head) suggests that secrets have a tendency to escape, much like body heat, despite efforts to contain them.

Matthews then reflects on the nature of certain secrets, noting that some "can't quit memory fast enough for human good." He provides a personal example, recalling the taste of a friend's wife's kisses and the decision not to sleep with her despite her "vernal allure." This candid confession emphasizes the moral and emotional complexities associated with secrets, hinting at the struggle between desire and ethical restraint.

The poem shifts to a broader societal critique with the mention of "Nixon's contempt for us," referring to the tapes from the Watergate scandal. Matthews questions the necessity of preserving such contemptuous words, comparing them to "preserved globs of spit." This imagery vividly conveys the repulsive nature of certain truths and the discomfort they can bring. The use of the term "transcript" highlights the cold, mechanical nature of recorded evidence, contrasting with the intimate, personal nature of individual secrets.

The poem continues with a cautionary note against hastily saving or preserving memories, using the metaphor of a "Save icon" and questioning the utility of preserving everything indiscriminately. Matthews likens this to how "a fossil fuel has to forget fossil to become fuel," suggesting that some aspects of the past must be transformed or left behind to be useful in the present. This metaphor also hints at the environmental and existential costs of extracting value from the past, whether in the form of memories or resources.

The mention of "how much childhood we plow under" further explores the theme of selective memory. It suggests that as we grow, we often bury parts of our past, especially childhood experiences, to move forward. This act of burying or forgetting is not portrayed as entirely negative; rather, it is presented as a necessary part of human development and survival.

The poem concludes with a reference to Tennyson's "Tears, idle tears," acknowledging that emotions, like tears, are not idle but serve a purpose. They "have their work cut out for them," much like a river carving a canyon over time. This simile elegantly captures the gradual, persistent impact of emotions and memories, shaping our internal landscapes much like natural forces shape the earth.

"Bucket's Got a Hole in It" is a meditation on the nature of memory, secrets, and the human tendency to selectively preserve or discard aspects of the past. Through its blend of personal anecdote, cultural reference, and philosophical reflection, the poem explores the complexity of dealing with memories and the importance of choosing what to remember or forget. Matthews' nuanced examination of these themes invites readers to consider their own relationships with their pasts and the secrets they hold.


Copyright (c) 2024 PoetryExplorer





Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!


Other Poems of Interest...



Home: PoetryExplorer.net