Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

William Stanley Merwin’s poem "Dreamers" is a complex and enigmatic exploration of consciousness, identity, and the mysterious processes of self-discovery. Through a series of surreal vignettes, Merwin delves into the nature of dreams, the search for meaning, and the often disorienting experience of waking to a reality that is both familiar and alien.

The poem begins with the image of a man who "can’t read" but "turned pages / until he came to one with his own story." This act of finding his own story, which "was air," suggests a search for self-identity in a world where meaning is elusive. The man’s realization that "the first letter seems wrong" when he begins learning to read hints at a deeper existential uncertainty. The traditional starting point, "A is for apple," feels inadequate or misleading, reflecting the difficulty of finding one’s true place in the world or the struggle to understand the language of life itself.

The second vignette describes a man who "swam upward / through dark water and came to air." The air, described as "the horizon," symbolizes a boundary or a threshold between different states of being—perhaps between unconsciousness and consciousness, or between life and something beyond. The horizon "opened / and let the sun out," an image that evokes both enlightenment and the passage of time. The man’s subsequent effort to "groping for the horizon / like the hands of a clock" suggests a cyclical, ongoing search for understanding that spans day and night, symbolizing the perpetual nature of this quest.

The third vignette presents a "man nothing but bones singing," whose notes "opened / and rose in the air and were air." This image combines the ethereal with the corporeal, as the man becomes the very notes he sings, each one transforming into air. The act of counting, "aloud including himself," only to find "one is missing," introduces a theme of incompleteness or loss. The missing element could represent something essential to the man’s identity or existence that remains elusive, echoing the poem’s broader theme of searching for meaning.

In the final vignette, the speaker reflects on a personal dream-like experience: "i think I fell asleep on a doorstep / inside someone was coming." The imagery here is both intimate and unsettling, with "white heads that were the best words I knew" waking "at that step for the first time and were true." This moment of awakening—when words become "true"—suggests a profound realization or insight gained through the dream. The speaker’s return to consciousness, "at the foot of the air / in summer," signals a rebirth or a new beginning, marked by the acquisition of a name and a sense of presence in the world ("my hand on a day of the world").

The poem’s structure, composed of four distinct yet interconnected vignettes, mirrors the fragmented and nonlinear nature of dreams. Each vignette presents a different aspect of the search for self-knowledge, whether through language, time, music, or personal experience. The recurring motif of air—a substance that is both everywhere and intangible—serves as a metaphor for the elusive nature of meaning and the ethereal quality of dreams.

"Dreamers" ultimately captures the fluidity of identity and the complexity of the human experience. Merwin suggests that the search for meaning is an ongoing process, one that is filled with uncertainties, revelations, and moments of profound insight. The poem invites readers to reflect on their own journeys of self-discovery, recognizing that, like the dreamers in the poem, we are all navigating a world where reality and imagination often blur, and where the truths we seek may be just out of reach. Through its rich imagery and contemplative tone, "Dreamers" offers a meditation on the nature of existence, the power of dreams, and the perpetual quest for understanding in a world full of mysteries.

Copyright (c) 2024 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...