Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

In "Of Being Numerous: 29," George Oppen reflects on the complexities of existence, the nature of familial relationships, and the elusive pursuit of happiness. The poem is deeply introspective, focusing on the speaker's relationship with his daughter and the shared reality they inhabit. Through his spare, deliberate language, Oppen explores themes of love, uncertainty, and the passage of time, while also delving into the ways in which we construct meaning and shelter ourselves from life's inherent uncertainties.

The poem opens with a direct and poignant address: "My daughter, my daughter, what can I say / Of living?" This line immediately sets a tone of vulnerability and uncertainty, as the speaker grapples with the weight of trying to convey the complexities of life to his child. The repetition of "my daughter" underscores the deep emotional connection between the speaker and his daughter, while the question "what can I say" reveals the speaker's struggle to find the right words or wisdom to impart.

The speaker then admits, "I cannot judge it," acknowledging the difficulty of making sense of life or passing judgment on it. This statement reflects a humble acceptance of the limitations of human understanding, particularly when it comes to the vast and multifaceted nature of existence. The speaker is aware of his own limitations and the impossibility of fully comprehending or explaining the intricacies of life to another person, even to someone as close as his daughter.

The line "We seem caught / In reality together my lovely / Daughter" emphasizes the shared experience of being "caught" in the complexities of reality. The use of the word "caught" suggests a sense of entrapment or being bound by the circumstances of life, while the word "together" highlights the bond between the speaker and his daughter, as they navigate this reality side by side. The speaker's affection for his daughter is evident in the phrase "my lovely / Daughter," which conveys both tenderness and concern.

Oppen then introduces a nuanced distinction: "I have a daughter / But no child." This line suggests a recognition of his daughter as an individual, distinct from the idealized or simplistic notion of a "child." The speaker acknowledges that his daughter is not merely an abstract concept or a possession but a person with her own complexities and agency. This distinction may also reflect the speaker's awareness of the gap between his expectations and the realities of parenthood, where the relationship with one's child is not always straightforward or easily defined.

The poem continues with a reflection on happiness: "And it was not precisely / Happiness we promised / Ourselves; / We say happiness, happiness and are not / Satisfied." Here, Oppen confronts the often elusive nature of happiness and the gap between what we promise ourselves and what we actually experience. The repetition of "happiness" emphasizes the speaker's—and perhaps society's—preoccupation with this ideal, yet the admission that "we are not / Satisfied" reveals the inherent dissatisfaction that accompanies the pursuit of happiness. This dissatisfaction suggests that happiness, as commonly understood, may be a flawed or incomplete goal, leaving individuals feeling unfulfilled despite their efforts.

The speaker then shifts to a more concrete image: "Tho the house on the low land / Of the city / Catches the dawn light." This description of a house bathed in dawn light offers a moment of beauty and tranquility, yet it is set against the backdrop of the "low land / Of the city," which may evoke a sense of vulnerability or precariousness. The house, as a symbol of stability and shelter, stands in contrast to the broader uncertainties and challenges of life.

Oppen's reflection deepens as he considers the passage of time and the role of belief: "I can tell myself, and I tell myself / Only what we all believe / True." This line suggests a reliance on shared beliefs or common wisdom as a way of coping with life's uncertainties. However, the phrase "tell myself" implies a certain degree of self-reassurance or perhaps even self-deception, as the speaker grapples with the need to find stability in an unstable world.

The poem then transitions into a contemplation of fear and its role in shaping human relationships: "In fear the roots grip / Downward / And beget / The baffling hierarchies / Of father and child." The metaphor of roots gripping downward in fear conveys a sense of entrenchment and the desire for security in the face of life's uncertainties. The "baffling hierarchies" between father and child suggest the complex and sometimes bewildering nature of familial roles and expectations, where fear and the need for protection can give rise to rigid structures and patterns of behavior.

The final lines of the poem return to the theme of time: "As of leaves on their high / Thin twigs to shield us / From time, from open / Time." Here, Oppen uses the image of leaves on thin twigs as a metaphor for the fragile defenses we construct to shield ourselves from the relentless passage of time. The phrase "open time" evokes a sense of time as an uncontrollable, ever-present force that we cannot fully escape or protect ourselves from. The image of the leaves, delicate and exposed, underscores the vulnerability inherent in the human condition and the fleeting nature of the protective measures we put in place.

In "Of Being Numerous: 29," George Oppen explores the complexities of life, the challenges of parenthood, and the elusive nature of happiness. The poem reflects on the ways in which we navigate the uncertainties of existence, seeking comfort in shared beliefs and relationships, even as we recognize the limitations of these constructs. Through his careful use of imagery and introspective tone, Oppen invites readers to consider the delicate balance between acceptance and resistance in the face of life's inevitable challenges.

Copyright (c) 2024 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...