Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Derek Walcott’s "It Depends" examines how perspective shapes one's understanding of a place, its people, and its culture. The poem presents a scene of a small church in a Caribbean village, but its meaning is refracted through the eyes of an outsider—someone whose interpretation is influenced by their background and preconceptions. Walcott juxtaposes the outsider’s view with a more nuanced, empathetic understanding of the place, emphasizing the role of context, history, and personal experience in shaping perception.

The opening lines introduce a "cream church on the cliff," an image that evokes both simplicity and isolation. The "rusted roof" and "stunted bell tower" suggest neglect or decay, and for someone from "another country," this could easily appear sad or desolate. Walcott hints that an outsider might view the church through a lens of pity or condescension, shaped by their own experiences and cultural expectations. The description of "white hard lilies" lining the road reinforces a sense of starkness and stillness, which contrasts with the vibrant life one might expect from a Caribbean setting.

The speaker introduces the figure of a priest in "boots and muddy clothes," evoking a sense of humility and hard work. The priest, who hails from "a county in Ireland," connects the Caribbean scene with a distant place where similar emotions might be evoked by "a stone chapel and low walls / heavy with time." The comparison between the two settings—the Caribbean and Ireland—suggests that the sadness perceived by the outsider is not unique to this particular church, but rather a reflection of a broader human condition, tied to history, time, and the harshness of life in rural or isolated places. The mention of "an iron sea" and "the history of the Celt" invokes Ireland’s cultural memory, hinting at a shared experience of suffering, survival, and resilience between these two seemingly disparate locations.

As the poem progresses, the speaker reflects on the outsider’s tendency to misinterpret the scene. The visitor may view the church and its surroundings through a colonial or patronizing lens, reducing the culture to "drumming and dancing, the ceremonies, the chants." This perspective sees the local customs and religious practices as exotic or primitive, reinforcing stereotypes about "the hope of black people" being rooted in a "sad magic." The phrase "sad magic" suggests a superficial understanding of the spiritual and cultural depth of the community, reducing it to something quaint or pitiable. The outsider’s dismissal of the "intricate, unlit labyrinth of their ignorance" underscores the dangers of imposing one’s own biases and assumptions onto a different culture.

However, the speaker offers an alternative perspective, one grounded in empathy and connection. The love that the speaker feels in the "veined, mottled hands" of the priest and the lilt of his Irish accent transforms the scene from one of sadness to one of quiet dignity and resilience. The priest’s presence, along with his connection to Ireland, evokes a sense of shared history and understanding between different cultures. The speaker's ability to recognize the beauty and significance in the small details—the priest’s hands, his voice—suggests a deeper, more compassionate engagement with the world.

Ultimately, "It Depends" highlights the subjectivity of perception and the importance of approaching other cultures with humility and openness. The poem critiques the tendency to view unfamiliar places through a lens of pity or exoticism, instead advocating for a more nuanced understanding that acknowledges the complexity and humanity of all people. By contrasting the outsider’s view with his own, Walcott emphasizes that how we look at the world is shaped by our own experiences, biases, and willingness to see beyond the surface. In doing so, the poem invites readers to reconsider their own perspectives and approach unfamiliar places and cultures with greater sensitivity and care.

Copyright (c) 2024 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...