Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"Only Ashes Know What It Means to Be Burned Out" by Joseph Brodsky is a vivid exploration of mortality, existential disillusionment, and the ephemeral nature of life. Brodsky, a Russian-American poet and Nobel laureate, masterfully unpacks the complexities of existence by employing the metaphor of ash-symbolizing the aftermath of life's consuming passions and endeavors.

The opening line, "Only ash knows, what it means to burn down," instantly compels the reader to think about the implications of living intensely, of burning oneself out. Ash becomes the embodiment of experience, a material manifestation of having lived and burned brightly, only to be reduced to remnants.

The subsequent lines present advice or perhaps a plea, suggesting that one should not "consume all the wind, not all of the broom." Here, wind may symbolize our aspirations or spiritual energy, and the broom our means of navigating life's complexities. The counsel seems to be urging moderation, a tempered approach to living, contrasting sharply with the opening line which implicitly praised the intensity symbolized by the ash.

The poem delves further into the concept of existence by imagining the end: "We will stay curled butt, spit, in the shadow / under the bench, where the angle of the beam to penetrate not give." The imagery is vivid, capturing the decay and neglect that await us all, as we merge "into humus, the sediment, in the cultural layer." This line, rich in its descriptiveness, captures the cyclic nature of life and death. We become part of the Earth, contributing to a new layer of history and culture, even in our decay.

One of the most striking parts of the poem is the portrayal of the archaeologist who will discover these remains. His "discovery of thunder / all over the world" casts a momentary spotlight on the buried, making them momentarily significant. But this is presented ironically, almost mockingly, as the poem calls this a "reverse version of the pyramids." Unlike pyramids, built to eternalize the significant, here the forgotten are momentarily unearthed only to exemplify decay and anonymity.

"I fell!" becomes a haunting proclamation towards the end, symbolizing the end of life, yet it is followed by the phrase "obhvativ life," suggesting a life fully grasped or embraced. Brodsky seems to imply that even in decay there is a form of freedom, "freedom from cells, freedom from / the whole: the apotheosis of the particles." In death, the elements that constituted 'us' are free to disperse, to become part of something larger or different-an apotheosis in their own right.

The poem is intricately layered, providing not just a bleak look at mortality but also offering a nuanced perspective on how one could approach life. It discusses the costs of living passionately versus the merits of a more measured existence, and it delves into the cyclical nature of life and death, emphasizing both the insignificance and the grandeur of individual existence. It leaves the reader pondering the complexities of life, the inevitability of decay, and the potential for transcendence even in the most mundane elements of existence.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...