Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"To the Girl Who Lives in a Tree" by Audre Lorde reflects a deeply nuanced and complex understanding of identity, relationships, and the dichotomies that govern human experience-between urbanity and nature, blackness and whiteness, freedom and constraint. Set in the context of a letter from the speaker to a girl who has made her way to Honduras, the poem deftly traverses multiple landscapes-emotional, geographical, and cultural.

The speaker opens with the mention of a letter in her mailbox, creating an atmosphere of distant connection. This distance is amplified by the girl's decision to leave the city and move to Honduras. The speaker's curiosity about the "color of the wood" the girl is chopping reflects a yearning to understand her friend's new life, one apparently so far removed from her own urban experience.

The speaker's emotional response to the girl's departure is complex. She admits to weeping for a year, her sorrow mapped onto the geography of 14th Street and Riverside Drive. Yet, she also acknowledges that in the girl's going, a "new country" was left for her, a landscape of self-renewal and self-discovery. Riverside Drive, a place in New York City, morphs into an "embattlement" that cannot be blasted free, suggesting the enduring emotional imprint of the girl's departure.

The poem delves deep into the complexities of identity. The girl's existence in the woods, chopping wood and battling the nightmares of her mothers', captures a form of rebellious agency, a challenge to conventional gender roles and cultural narratives. The speaker also implicates race, insisting, "we both know you are not white." The girl's whiteness is seen as the result of "bleeding too much while trudging behind a wagon," a nod to the often brutal history of westward expansion and colonial conquest in America.

In contrast, the speaker's "mothers' nightmares" involve being unable to wipe away a child's blood while her "chained black hand" is immobilized. This evokes the atrocities of slavery and the historical trauma it left in its wake. The speaker argues that these racialized nightmares, while different, are "just as binding" for both women, thus linking their experiences.

Toward the end of the poem, the speaker returns to the issue of choice, this time concerning the girl's eventual decision between "loving women or loving trees." Interestingly, she suggests that "from the standpoint of free movement, women win hands down," perhaps indicating that relationships offer a more immediate form of liberation than solitary communion with nature.

"To the Girl Who Lives in a Tree" is a profound meditation on the intricacies of identity, love, and the ties that bind us-whether to people, places, or histories. Through its poetic narrative, it questions the choices we make, the identities we inhabit, and the dreams and nightmares that shape us. It proposes that while our histories may differ drastically, the very act of acknowledging these differences can pave the way for deeper understanding and more meaningful connections.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...